Justin P 1:47 Sat Mar 5
Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
|
I wouldnt
|
|
|
Replies - Newest Posts First ( Show In Chronological Order)
madeeasy
4:57 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
Needs to cut out these little last second kick ups though.
Stop the show boating, we've got games to win. all looks good until it goes wrong...
Silly mistakes like that, that costs us a game can quickly damage morale
|
TeVaz
8:52 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
Adrian has been superb this season . Far from being overrated , I don't think he gets the credit he deserves . Tremendous team spirit at the club so I wouldn't swap anyone for anyone .
|
cholo
8:44 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
I'm biased and I like Adrian, so even though he gives me the shits sometimes, I'd keep him over Hart even though Hart is probably the better all round keeper, because sometimes football is about feeling rather than stone cold logic.
|
icwhs
1:44 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
I think the pair are overrated? And prefer Adrián,
When you think of past great England goalkeepers, Banks, Clemence, Parkes, Corrigan, Shilton.....Seaman was ok, Hart won't get a mention, press and other people's opinions basically, just because he plays for a rich team, doesn't make him better than he is? Adam Johnson played there as well, and for England
|
:^)
1:32 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
By who, you lot seem to think Adrian is better?
|
icwhs
1:17 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
Yes..he's overrated
|
VirginiaHam
1:13 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
El Scorchio 6:49 Mon Mar 7
I get what you're saying. Mignolet did the same needling shit against us during the cup game. I just like nice, safe goalkeepers
When it all goes tits up it doesn't look very clever. I loved EE getting after Lloris...he nearly fucked up too.
|
:^)
1:03 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
Joe Hart has been at one of the richest clubs in the world and played over 300 times, got over 50 caps for his country and HE is overrated?
|
icwhs
12:58 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
Both overrated, Adrián better, so no.
|
NCHammer
12:52 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
No. I am one who believes Joe Hart is massively overrated.
|
SilverSurfer
12:28 Tue Mar 8
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
nope
|
Lato
8:08 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
No we are also fortunate that Randolph is imo as good as Adrian. How many teams can boast they have 2 top keepers? I can only think of Chelsea in recent years Cech/Cudicini and Courtois/Cech
|
El Scorchio
6:49 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
VirginiaHam 5:49
Weirdly, that's one of the things I like about him.
Bit of showboating, needle and gamesmanship and riling up the opposition.
Just looks bloody stupid if he ever gets caught out doing it- i.e. Southampton last season with the later rescinded red card.
|
Robson
6:30 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
City have conceded just two fewer goals than us this season. In fact they have a game in hand and are conceding one per game on average so make that one fewer goals conceded.
Plus our defence is considerably cheaper than theirs and has been ravaged by injury throughout the season, which puts Adrian at a disadvantage.
How much better off do you think we'd be with Hart between the sticks?
|
VirginiaHam
5:49 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
If it's any help, I don't like Adrian's juggling games when a forward is about 3 inches away, or the occasional leaps in the air for no good reason.
I like nice calm, no nonsense get the job done goalkeepers, and I think Hart is a bit too mouthy too.
Leaning towards Randolph.
|
JonWHUFC
5:48 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
Madeeasy has hit the nail on the head about the squad at the moment. The togetherness is there for all to see. I have not heard one mumbling of unrest over players not in the team. I think they all get the "If you have the shirt and do well you keep the shirt" policy. Bringing in new players who fit into this mindset will prove challenging but we have absolutely the right man in charge to do it. So, I agree with Made, Adrian for me all day long.
|
Yarmouth
5:31 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
I think Adrian is a good keeper and Randolph is equal in my view, but Hart edges them both so yes for me.
|
Admiral Lard
5:25 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
NO - Adrian and Randolph between them are doing an oustandaing job!
|
madeeasy
4:56 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
I wouldn't swap him for one reason.
He loves being at West Ham and is part of the personality that surrounds the club and players right now and is an integral part of our team spirit that has the players playing for each other and believing.
Hart maybe better but I feel that spirit is worth the extra few points over a season, that he may let in, that Hart would save. He's loving being part of West Ham and that means a lot right now.
Leicester, West Ham, Bournemouth, Stoke, Watford are all proving this season that having team spirit and belief is better than having super stars and a super star manager
|
kylay
4:50 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
No.Hart does not show up in big moments. Makes good reflex saves, but is prone to mental mistakes. I think he's a bit of a head case. Adrian has his weaknesses but he comes up big when it matters. Plus he's a great character
|
Fifth Column
3:58 Mon Mar 7
Re: Would you take Joe Hart over Adrian?
|
Hart is minorly ahead of Adrian for me. In the long term I think Butland will be much better than both.
|
| 
